NEW YORK - When does a smartphone make you dumb?
When you're driving.
Dialing or texting on a phone is a proven distraction when you're behind the wheel. And as "smart" as today's phones are, they can't compensate for human folly. Phone makers and software developers are making a valiant effort to create elegant technical solutions, but, try as they might, they've yet to solve the problem of distracted driving.
Article Photos
AP Photo
Prosecutor Ashlee Logan shows jurors a photograph from an auto crash during the trial of Aaron Deveau in Haverhill District Court May 29 in Haverhill, Mass. Deveau — the first person to be tried in Massachusetts on a charge of motor vehicle homicide while texting — was found guilty in the death of Donald Bowley of Danville, N.H. and later sentenced to 2 1/2 years in prison.
A new survey, released by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention last week, exposes just how severe the problem is -especially among young drivers. In the survey, about 58 percent of high school seniors said they had texted or emailed while driving during the previous month. About 43 percent of high school juniors acknowledged they did the same thing.
Thirty-nine states ban texting behind the wheel for all age groups, and an additional five states outlaw it for novice teen drivers. Even so, Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood said distracted driving is "a national epidemic".
The industry doesn't have a surefire cure.
There's a bevy of phone applications (or apps) that silence a phone when they detect that the device is moving at car speed. Although they carry names like "SecuraFone" these solutions all have limitations that prevent them from being widely adopted.
One big shortcoming is that they can't tell drivers from passengers.
Most of the apps assume any phone that's travelling at more than 10 miles per hour belongs to a driver. Of course, that phone might belong to someone in the back seat, or on a bus or train.
That means these apps come with easy override buttons -which could also be used by a driver. The app isn't "smart" enough to know the difference.
On the plus side, these apps are "generally reliable," said Russ Rader, spokesman for the Insurance Institute of Highway Safety.
They're also a lot cheaper than they were when they debuted two or three years ago.
At the time, app developers figuring that safety was priceless, charged around $40 for their products, plus recurring fees of around $4 per month. Now, Sprint Nextel Corp. gives away its Drive First app and charges $2 per month for the service.
ZoomSafer and CellControl are two companies that offer slightly more sophisticated solutions: apps that make sure you're in your car before putting the phone in "driver mode."
The phone listens for a wireless signal, either from the car's built-in electronic system or from a proprietary device that plugs into the engine-diagnostics port.
The phone is wirelessly linked to the car, so people who don't usually drive the vehicle can ride as passengers without having their phones go silent.
Using these apps, a driver who leaves his car behind and rides the bus won't have his phone silenced.
