AUSTIN, Texas - What if No. 8 West Virginia and No. 11 Texas played Saturday and decided not to bring their defenses?
At the rate those two have been giving up big plays for touchdowns, would it really matter?
The Mountaineers (4-0, 1-0 Big 12) needed every one of quarterback Geno Smith's eight touchdown passes in last week's 70-63 victory against Baylor that left its defense looking as bad as its offense looked spectacular.
Texas quarterback David Ash, above, and WVU’s Geno Smith are 1-2 nationally in passing efficiency.
The Longhorns (4-0, 1-0) have a 45-0 shutout of New Mexico on their resume, but also have a glaring habit of missing tackles and giving up long touchdowns, trouble signs in a matchup against a quarterback of Smith's caliber.
"It was terrible," West Virginia safety Darwin Cook said after Baylor scored nine touchdowns. "It gets you down. We don't like giving up points like that, at all, but you just have to get back up and play the next game. We have to get better on defense."
So does Texas.
A unit that was supposed to rank among the best in the Big 12 and the country is now talking about inexperience at linebacker and the middle of the defensive line.
That doesn't explain the missed tackles and broken coverages in a secondary filled with game-tested veterans. The Longhorns have surrendered five touchdowns of 44 plays or longer this season. Smith had four touchdown passes of 39 yards or longer against Baylor just in the second half.
Texas coach Mack Brown says his team missed 12 tackles in last week's 41-36 win at Oklahoma State, giving up 109 yards and two touchdowns. It wasn't clear if he was including the second play from scrimmage when Cowboys running back Joseph Randle juked Texas safety Kenny Vaccaro on a 69-yard touchdown run.
Vaccaro's whiff could hardly be called a missed tackle because he was nowhere close to laying a hand on Randle.
"It is frustrating to give up so many points and big plays," said Texas cornerback Carrington Byndom, who insists the Texas defense hasn't lost the swagger it started the season with.
"We still know the kind of defense we can play," Byndom said.
Texas ranks just 63rd nationally in total defense. The Mountaineers are No. 106.
Brown says the missed tackles are part of the spread offense era of college football. Offenses are designed to put defenders in one-on-one matchups and one broken tackle can lead to a touchdown.
"It's a problem across the country," Brown said.
He also sounds like he's had enough, suggesting Texas may have some new starters on defense against the Mountaineers.
"If we've got four weeks of a guy missing tackles, we've got to start looking at another guy," Brown said without identifying any specific players.
But he's also sensitive about not tearing down his own players too much. Brown still needs a confident bunch to face Smith and the high-flying circus the Mountaineers call their offense.
Brown emphasized what he liked from his defense last week: an interception to set up an early touchdown and holding Oklahoma State to a late field goal that let Texas drive for the winning score with 29 seconds left.
"Nobody will give our defense credit this week. Everybody will bash them. Let's give them credit for what they did," Brown said.
West Virginia may have as much trouble handling Texas' offense.
The Mountaineers gave up 700 yards of total offense against Baylor and now face Texas quarterback David Ash, who ranks second only to Smith nationally in pass efficiency. Ash passed for 304 yards against Oklahoma State, making him just the fourth quarterback in Texas history to post consecutive 300-yard games.
Smith urged his defense not to lose confidence. If the Mountaineers have to score 10 touchdowns again to win, so be it.
"I don't want the defense to hold their heads (down) because it's a team game," Smith said. "Whatever it takes to get a victory is what we'll do."