Phyllis Hendershot Costine, 92, of St. Clairsville, OH died Sunday, January 17, 2021 at her home. She was born January 27, 1928 in Barnesville, OH., a daughter of the late Theodore Clifford and Lillie Yockey Hendershot.

Phyllis was a teacher and homemaker. She lived a long, full and active life dedicated to family, church and music, Those who knew her will remember her warm, elegant and gen- uine style. She was a graduate of Beallsville High School in 1945 and graduated from West Liberty University in 1949. She was a member of Thoburn United Methodist Church for many years serving in the Choir, she loved to sing. She was very active in many organizations; the Tuesday Night Club for 50 years, Thoburn Choir for 50 years, a Sunday School Teacher, Girl Scout Leader and a proud St. Clairsville High School Band parent.

In addition to her parents, she was preceded in death by a granddaughter, Hannah Costine.

Surviving are her husband of 69 years, John O. Costine of St. Clairsville; her children, Ret. Judge J. Mark (Brenda) Costine of St. Clairsville, Melanie (Craig) Moon of Middletown, OH., Judge Eric (Denise) Costine of St. Clairsville; a brother, John (Mabel) Hendershot of Frostproof, FL; a sister, Judy Norris of Franklin, TN; six grandchildren; two great-grandchildren.

Her greatest achievement was her close and inseparable marriage with her husband. All who know them admired this relationship.

Due to COVID-19 pandemic, social distancing and masks are required.

Friends will be received on Wednesday from 2-4 & 6-8 pm at Thoburn United Methodist Church with funeral services on Thursday at 1 pm with Rev. Tom Jones officiating. Burial in Union Cemetery, St. Clairsville.

Arrangements by Toothman Funeral Home, St. Clairsville.

Memorial contributions may be made to Thoburn United Methodist Church Choir or Thoburn United Methodist Church.