Man Ejected, Public Speaks Out Over Purchase Option
Trending
WHEELING -- Voices were raised -- and one man was ejected -- at the council meeting Tuesday, where first reading of an ordinance regarding the potential purchase of land for the city's public safety building was heard.
Wheeling resident and mayoral candidate Jerry Jacobs asked council if the public would have a chance to comment on the proposal put forth by Councilman Dave Palmer, which would give the city the option to pay 19th Street property owner Frank Calabrese $150,000 for his blighted building and also set aside another $195,000 for environmental remediation of the site. The city would seek a federal Brownfields remediation grant to clean up the site and, if it's granted, would give the $195,000 that is to be placed in escrow for remediation to Calabrese.
Council did not allow any public comment until the end of the noon meeting.
At that time, Jacobs spent more than a minute and a half arguing with council member Wendy Scatterday. Both talked over each other as they debated whether council understands and follows Robert's Rules of Order, a manual of parliamentary procedure. His three-minute time allotment was reset after the dispute was settled and he started again.
"After hearing some of the things discussed here, I'm amazed at how people aren't aware of the things going on here, though you all say, 'Transparency, transparency,'" Jacobs said. "Come May, I'm very hopeful that the citizens of Wheeling will come together and vote every single one of you out of office."
Jacobs asked a series of questions regarding the property for the public safety building, but each question was met with silence from council.
Vice Mayor Chad Thalman invited Jacobs to speak with council members after the meeting to discuss the matter at greater length.
"I'm upset with the council because there's been no discussion, so where are you guys discussing this? In back rooms, where we don't have any chance?" Jacobs asked.
Wheeling resident Josh Riffle also signed up to speak. He accused council of violating state code by regulating audience members' comment period to three minutes.
"This three minutes is illegal by state code," Riffle said, citing section 6-9-A-3(c) of the West Virginia State Code. "There's plenty of space here (in the audience). Three minutes, uh-uh. You can't do that, by the state rules. State trumps city, it's that simple."
The section of the code Riffle referred to states that governing bodies may set and enforce "reasonable rules" at any meeting where there is not enough room for all members of the public to address the body. Riffle used the relatively small list of registered speakers to indicate that the public deserved more time. He also criticized the signup requirement to speak at the end of meetings.
"I'm not a doctor or a lawyer. I'm a regular layperson, and I don't need a lawyer to read for me," he said.
Riffle then left the podium, approaching council members while rifling through a bag, prompting Police Chief Shawn Schwertfeger to escort him away. Schwertfeger later said Riffle posed a danger to council, and he acted on his own initiative to remove him.
"You serve us, and I'm sitting here telling you how to do that. The cops aren't stopping me, because they understand that, too," he said, just before Schwertfeger intervened.
As Riffle was escorted by police to gather his things and leave, council moved to adjourn.
At the start of the meeting, Riffle also had briefly interrupted the proceedings to object to Councilman Ken Imer's recitation of prayer, saying the action was inappropriate for a governmental official at a public meeting. After his objection, Imer continued.
Also speaking Tuesday was Helen Potter, who criticized council's purchase agreement for the land. She said she believes the site could be acquired for less money if claimed through eminent domain.
"Apparently you're not using (eminent domain) -- you people are knocking yourselves out trying to get Frank Calabrese as much money as possible. … " Potter said. "It's ridiculous. He should be paying us."
Potter told council members that they ran the risk of violating federal law through the arrangement by giving federal funds to Calabrese. She added that if the deal went ahead, she would seek to inform federal agents of the situation and request that they investigate the matter.
"I hate to tell you people, that's a federal offense. You can't ask the federal government money for cleanup, then turn around and give it to Calabrese. … I know why he's doing it -- I can't figure out why you're doing it. This is a joke."
Council held the first reading of the land purchase ordincance, and the heads of the police and fire departments both implored council to move ahead with the purchase.
"Not only does it meet that (space) requirement, it also gives us a large footprint that we could build a one-story facility and be more cost-effective, because we wouldn't need to build at a higher cost for multiple floors," Fire Chief Larry Helms said. "That's the biggest thing I love about this property. Even though we're building for the future, it still gives us a lot of property that, if we need to expand, it's still available."
Schwertfeger said the "inadequate" space of the current building is a concern for the police department.
"It's soon to be 2020. It's time that we do the right thing, provide our officers with a functional environment to work in, and come prepared to do their duties," he said. "I find (the site) to be very adequate, the location is good. I think we'd be a great neighbor in that area of the city, and certainly … the design and ultimate structure itself would fit nicely there."
Jacobs had sent a letter to council, and to the media, listing several of his questions about the property. In particular, Jacobs asked whether the city had the site professionally assessed, including considerations such as the quality of the land beneath the foundation, the presence of hazardous materials such as asbestos, the potential costs of remediation of any contaminants found, and whether a written report on any findings would be made available.
"Even if you could validate that the majority of your taxpayers support the construction of a new public safety building, your lack of due diligence in investigating the extent, and cost to remediate any contamination, would be a gross dereliction of your duties as elected officials," Jacobs stated. "Remember that once the city obtains ownership of this property, they will forever be responsible for all the costs of demolition and abatement and remediation, even if the site is not used for a public safety building."
City Manager Robert Herron did not provide answers to the questions Jacobs posed, but said that he would have further information at future council meetings.
"Once we get a little further along -- first of all, it's still under negotiation, but once we get some signed documents, I'll talk about it more," Herron said.