East Palestine Residents Taking Precautions as They Settle Back Into Their Homes
Trending
EAST PALESTINE -- While reports of animals and pets becoming ill in East Palestine following the derailment continue, a number of residents haven't experienced any such issues but are still taking precautions as they settle back into their homes.
Respected longtime area educator and coach Dan McKinstry said when he first heard the derailment occur late in the evening Feb. 3 that he didn't think very much of it initially.
"Trains go through town a lot; it wasn't until I suddenly heard tons of fire trucks and ambulances that I let the dogs into the backyard and went to see what was going on. The flames from the tracks were enormous," said McKinstry.
McKinstry said that he then called his neighbors to see if they knew what had happened, and they told him about the derailment. McKinstry also said that he had seen derailments in the past, but that this derailment "wasn't like anything I've ever seen before."
The next day McKinstry sheltered in place at his home after hearing about the full extent of the derailment, saying he didn't want to leave his home unless he was forced. The day after that, he took his dogs for a walk, and when he returned home found a sheriff's deputy going door to door ordering residents to evacuate in preparation for the controlled burn off.
"My wife was in Columbus at the time spending some time with our grandkids. So, I called her and had her tell me what she needed for a few days, and packed her bag, and packed up my stuff, and started to look for a hotel that was dog friendly because we have four dachshunds," said McKinstry.
McKinstry found his dog friendly location in the Quality Inn in North Lima, and with his and his wife's bags packed and their four dogs, arrived there at around 2 p.m. The McKinstrys remained there through Wednesday Feb. 8, and it was there they watched Gov. Mike Dewine announce the evacuation order had been lifted. After having the air in their home tested, they returned home that evening.
"The inn was very kind to us and very accommodating of our situation," praised McKinstry.
McKinstry said he spent Thursday airing out his home because he thought he could smell an unusual odor despite the results of the air test. McKinstry says that there's still an odor lingering in the area, particularly in the mornings.
"I can smell something. The smell is still lingering in the morning, and downtown you can smell something. There's still something there," said McKinstry.
Since he returned home McKinstry has been having issues with his nose running "nearly constantly," and said that he had gotten sick Thursday evening and continued feeling unwell into Friday. However, McKinstry said that at some point during his evacuation his home had lost power as a result of the derailment and subsequent cleanup efforts, and both himself and his doctor were unable to determine if his illness was a result of eating food that had gone bad while the power was out or due to potential exposure to airborne chemicals while he was working outside Thursday evening.
McKinstry was the only one who had experienced any ill effects in his household, with both his wife and dogs having no issues or symptoms since returning Wednesday evening. McKinstry also said that he hasn't seen any signs of dead or sick animals other than the recent reports of Taylor Holzer's foxes becoming ill on the news, despite being an active walker, and that he hasn't encountered anyone who has. McKinstry did note, however, that neighbors who themselves have a new baby and two dogs had not yet returned home.
"That doesn't mean it hasn't happened. I just haven't come into contact with anybody," said McKinstry.
In spite of this McKinstry still "has some reservations" about the safety of the air and water in the area, citing the lingering odor, noting that both himself and his wife only drink bottled water and have done so for a few years; however, since returning home they have also been giving their dogs exclusively bottled water.
"I don't feel comfortable giving [the water] to the dogs just yet to be safe. I know the reports say it's safe and I'm sure the people doing the tests have done a good job, but if there's even a chance that this is safer for them, I'm willing to do it," said McKinstry.
McKinstry also said he was concerned about the safety of the soil following the chemical release, and that while he knows the affected soil is being excavated and hauled away, he fears that they will penetrate to deeply into the ground and linger.
"I don't think normal, as we knew normal, is ever going to truly return," said McKinstry.
Not all residents felt so favorably about their experience. Cassie Holsopple described the evacuation experience of themself, their husband and baby, and their pets, (three cats and one dog), as "very stressful" overall, noting there was difficulty finding official information when the derailments first occurred.
"There were a lot of rumors going around, making it difficult to understand what was really going on," said Holsopple.
While the Holsopples initially considered evacuating Friday night, Cassie said that after contacting the non-emergency police line they were told the evacuation order had been lifted. However, the next day there was an extremely unpleasant odor in the house, so they felt it was best to evacuate and stay with family in the area.
"The next day the house smelled really bad so we decided to get out. Luckily, we had family in Columbiana who were able to take in our whole family," said Holsopple.
Holsopple attempted to return home Thursday morning after the evacuation order was lifted, but began to experience a burning sensation in their throat soon after they arrived, so they left and returned the next day. Holsopple said their throat "burned a bit for a few days" but they have had no other symptoms themselves, and that nobody else in their household has experienced any symptoms.
Holsopple also said their pets had been doing well since returning and that all of them "seem healthy and are behaving normally," and that they were glad they had been able to take them with them when they evacuated.
While many residents have cited concerns over potential issues with the air quality, Holsopple feels it is most likely safe. However, the Holsopples are more dubious of the conditions of the water and recently purchased a 5-gallon water cooler to avoid drinking city water, and that they may reconsider using city water in a few months.
"I just hope they remain committed to testing the air and water and don't leave prematurely," said Holsopple.
Residents' concerns that soil may be contaminated are shared by the Ohio Farm Bureau, which also cited concerns that groundwater in the area may be contaminated.
"We are concerned that the groundwater and soil might be contaminated. We know that our farms typically rely on groundwater to use for their livestock. We are encouraging everyone to take samples and get them tested," said Nick Kennedy, Ohio Farm Bureau Organization director representing farm bureaus in Columbiana, Mahoning, Portage and Stark counties
While Kennedy said the bureau had not yet received any reports of livestock becoming ill or dying from exposure in the affected area yet, they have been in contact with a few veterinarians and have been encouraging anyone whose livestock do become ill to notify their local veterinarian.
Should someone believe their livestock have died as a result of exposure the only way to confirm this is through a necropsy, which is comparable to an autopsy in humans, and determines the cause of death.
"The state veterinarian would more than likely work with livestock owners if necropsy is needed," said Kennedy.
While the farm bureau has yet to receive any reports of livestock dying, Columbiana County Humane Society Executive Director Teresa McGuire said they had been receiving reports "non-stop" and had received reports of animals becoming ill or dying from at least 20 families by Monday afternoon, and the number had only grown since.
McGuire said that Tuesday morning they had received a detailed letter including reports from the veterinarian from one person whose pet had become severely ill and had been forced to seek treatment from a specialty clinic in Pittsburgh. The cost of treatment would have been thousands of dollars; however, when these expenses were turned into Norfolk Southern's family assistance center they were told that they would not honor the claim as it was not among the specified expenses, but that they could file an appeal later. McGuire said that the owners were unable to pay for the treatment without financial assistance and were forced to euthanize the animal.
McGuire said that anyone whose veterinarian diagnoses their animal with issues related to chemicals released during the derailment and subsequent controlled burn can send the veterinarian's report to the humane society by email at columbianacountyhumanesociety@gmail.com.
McGuire said that all veterinarians reports received this way are being printed off and compiled in a file.
"The bigger our file gets the more insistent we are becoming, and the more reports we have the more we can help," said McGuire.
McGuire stressed the importance of reports from veterinarians in this matter as they can be acted on directly; however, she also noted that any videos of pets acting strangely or ill could also be submitted and utilized moving forward.
McGuire also said that most of the reports they've received have included a veterinarian's report verifying the animal's condition, and within a reasonable distance to be affected by any chemical release, with most being within a 1- to 2-mile radius of the derailment site and some in the Beaver Falls and Chippewa area also being within a reasonable radius.
"Obviously we have to filter through some reports that are a little unreasonable, but there's definitely validity to many of these reports," said McGuire.
The humane society is urging pet owners not to allow their pets to drink out of any standing water as they return to their homes.
Anyone who believes their pet has become ill due to exposure should contact their local veterinarian immediately, and anyone who believes they have died as a result should contact a veterinarian for a necropsy as it is the only way to confirm potential exposure as the cause of death.