Breaking News
Top Headlines

West Virginia House of Delegates Passes Student Discipline Bill

By STEVEN ALLEN ADAMS 5 min read

CHARLESTON - A bill passed by the West Virginia House of Delegates Tuesday that would spell out specific requirements for student discipline raised concerns with both Democratic and Republican lawmakers.

House Bill 2890, modifying student discipline in the classroom, passed the House Tuesday in a 79-16 vote, sending the bill to the state Senate.

HB 2890 requires students in kindergarten through 12th grade who are removed from the classroom for disruptive behavior be prohibited from returning to the classroom the remainder of the day and count as an in-school suspension. If the student has to be removed from class three times in a one-month period, the student must receive an out-of-school suspension. The bill also empowers principals to move students to different classrooms if that might help alleviate disruptive behavior.

“The bill before you is about rights and responsibilities,” said House Majority Whip Marty Gearheart, R-Mercer, the lead sponsor of the bill. “Students in the State of West Virginia have the right to receive an education, but they also have a responsibility to behave in the classroom so as to not deny others from receiving that education … you can’t be a participant in a class if you’re going to constantly disrupt it.”

The bill also requires teachers who send students to the principal for disorderly conduct to file an electronic report with the West Virginia Education Information System. The bill requires county boards of education to develop a tiered system with teacher input to develop a framework for student behaviors and punishments. It also protects the teacher from punishment as long as their actions fall within the law and the new tiered system for student behavior and punishment.

According to a report on school disciplinary actions released last July by the state Department of Education covering a five-year period between the 2017-2018 and 2021-2022 school years, there were 173,455 disciplinary referrals last school year. That number includes 32,613 in-school suspensions making up 19.16% of all actions and interventions, and 30,011 out-of-school suspensions (17.63%).

Concern has been raised over the last several years about racial disparities when it comes to student discipline. According to the Department of Education report, 9.4% of in-school suspensions were Black students during the 2021-2022 school year, while 9.8% of out-of-school suspensions were Black students.

Senate Bill 723, passed by the Legislature in 2020, required the Department of Education to look at statewide data on school disciplinary actions and develop a plan to reduce the number of disciplinary actions. The department is required to submit a report to the Legislative Oversight Commission on Education Accountability every two years.

While the department released its data report last summer, it did not release any plan to address disparity issues as required by the new law. Some members of the state Board of Education and leaders in the Black community were unhappy with the data, which they said was too broad and didn’t provide school-level data needed to target schools with the largest disparities.

“The reason (SB 723) ran a few years ago was because we have extremely high suspension and expulsion rates in West Virginia. The bill was meant to address that,” said Delegate Mike Pushkin, D-Kanawha. “We’ve yet to see the plan, so what we’re doing today is the opposite of what that bill set out to do. (HB 2890) will lead to increased suspension and expulsion rates in a state that unfortunately leads the nation in those rates.”

To address complaints from Black leaders and some members of the Board of Education, state Superintendent of Schools David Roach in December said the department would expand the scope of the original data report, as well as release a plan to address the disparity issue.

House Education Committee Minority Chairman Sean Hornbuckle, D-Cabell, said HB 2890 would add to the number of discipline disparities instead of helping to alleviate discipline issues.

“We understand and know that we have these issues when it comes to suspensions and expulsions,” Hornbuckle said. “We also know that we have issues with students with disabilities and minority children when it comes to suspensions and expulsions, disproportionately and astronomically higher. I understand we need to be helping our teachers in the classroom, but this isn’t the way to do it.”

Democratic House members, led by Hornbuckle and Delegates Danielle Walker, D-Monongalia, Kayla Young, D-Kanawha, and Elliott Pritt, D-Fayette, Tuesday offered five amendments to the bill with the Republican majority voting down each amendment by either voice vote or by large margins.

One of the failed amendments would eliminate language from the bill allowing students to be removed from classrooms and be reassigned if the behavior of the student is due to a “personality clash,” which is undefined in the bill. Delegate Brandon Steele, R-Raleigh, raised concerns that personality clashes could be used as an excuse by teachers to remove a student from their classroom over political disagreements.

“I think we’re opening the door here for political disagreement to result in your child being excluded from school,” Steele said. “Can you not see that happening here with personality conflict? I do, I see it plain as day. This undefined term, this vague term, could be twisted to where a young person exploring their beliefs and ideas could be excluded from the education process because the teacher has a personality conflict with that child’s views.”

Starting at /week.