Breaking News
Top Headlines

More Bite Sought for Wheeling City Codes on Barking, Animal Cruelty

By ERIC AYRES 4 min read

WHEELING -- City officials want to put more teeth in Wheeling’s ordinances pertaining to barking dogs - not only to protect residents affected by the noise but also to help protect animals themselves.

Members of the Rules Committee of Wheeling City Council recently met for a discussion that began with a proposal to amend the city’s codified ordinances regarding cruelty to animals.

"This got started because there was a resident in East Wheeling who reached out to the mayor and was concerned that there was a dog barking -- howling in misery -- often left outside 24 hours a day in minimal shelter," Vice Mayor Chad Thalman said. "After taking a look at our cruelty to animals ordinances, there is a section that says that animals should not be withheld from shelter that protect them from the elements of weather."

However, Thalman said the resident reached out to several individuals in the city and was told that the city ordinances do not give them the ability to do anything about the issue.He hoped the city could tighten up existing ordinances and give authorities more power to protect the animals.

Thalman proposed addlng language to the existing city ordinance addressing cruelty to animals to state that, "any animal kept outside shall be provided a structurally sound, weather-proof enclosure large enough to accommodate the animal with adequate room for movement and insulated to protect the animal from extreme heat or cold temperatures."

Wheeling City Solicitor Rose Humway-Warmuth said that the Ohio County Dog Warden or a humane officer have the authority to obtain warrants to be served in the company of a law enforcement officer from the city’s police department or the county sheriff’s office.

"The additions that have been suggested really do not materially change the state of West Virginia or our ordinance," she said. "It perhaps could give a bit more clarity."

Humway-Warmuth said there have been instances in West Virginia where a humane officer initiated cases that were prosecuted through the state courts. Yet officials said the particular case in East Wheeling was investigated on several occasions, and the dog was not found to be neglected.

"The dog was on a covered porch and was cared for, but when it was outside, it did bark excessively," City Manager Robert Herron said.

Thalman said he would like to see something done that would give the police department or the dog warden a "little more teeth, so to speak, to protect these animals that are left out in the cold."

Many council members agreed that it was a good idea to seek stronger language in the city code. Councilman Ben Seidler said issues that need to be addressed go beyond simply enforcement against cruelty to animals but also against the city’s noise ordinances.

"I think that this problem is a large problem, and the issue in East Wheeling is certainly not an isolated issue," Seidler said. "This is a thing that I get lots of complaints about on the Island."

Seidler said he has communicated these complaints to the city’s police and legal departments in the past.

"Just the noise part of this alone is a huge issue," Seidler said. "It’s something I get complaints about very, very frequently."

There is a process in place that involves calling the police department, but some of those processes are ineffective, according to Seidler.

"The last thing I want as a city council member is to call a police officer and ask them to go out and sit in front of a house and listen to a dog bark non stop for 20 minutes or for a continuous period of time," Seidler said. "It’s not a very good use of our officers’ time. At the same time, I don’t know what the solution is."

Seidler suggested that the city could tighten up verbiage around noise ordinance as well to attack the problem at both ends.

"I don’t know if this ordinance does anything in regard to what I think we’re trying to accomplish," said Councilman Jerry Sklavounakis, an attorney by trade.

Officials suggested that language to address both the animal cruelty and noise issues could be explored by the legal department with the idea of strengthening enforceability.

Rule Committee members - which include Thalman as chairman, along with Sklavounakis and Palmer - asked the legal department to bring back a proposal for possible amendments to the city code to address these issues. The matter is expected to be revisited during another Rules Committee meeting prior to the next regular meeting of Wheeling City Council on March 21.

Starting at /week.