Response to Planned Pride Event Sparks Fireworks at Wheeling City Council Meeting
Trending
WHEELING - A lengthy Wheeling City Council meeting Tuesday night ended with a heated discussion during the end of the session opened to those wishing to be heard, prompting one councilman to storm out of the room.
The short presentation by Fulton resident Carlee Dittmar also prompted Mayor Glenn Elliott Jr. to verify whether or not she was speaking on her own behalf as a citizen or in her role as the chair of the Ohio County Republican Party Executive Committee.
Dittmar, an outspoken regular visitor to Wheeling City Council meetings, has taken the podium at the end of several regular meetings in recent years, offering sharp criticism and opposing opinions from a conservative viewpoint of various council actions and of other current city topics.
On Tuesday night, Dittmar spoke out against what she said appeared to be city support for "Pride on the Plaza," scheduled to take place in Wheeling in conjunction with Pride Month in June.
Before Dittmar spoke, however, the mayor asked her to explain recent correspondence she sent to him.
"Miss Dittmar, before you begin I’d like to respond to an email you sent me, if that’s OK," Elliott said. "Two things - you emailed me suggesting that I silenced you during the last meeting, and all I did was ask you to stop speaking at the end of your allotted time. And you said that I silence all of the people you represent, so I guess I was just going to ask - are you speaking as Carlee Ditmar or are you speaking as …"
Dittmar interjected.
"I speak as Carlee Dittmar - as the mouthpiece for all of the emails and all of the phone calls, just as I have in the past, and am doing it here again tonight," she said. "When I talk about the Fulton Playground, that’s for me."
The mayor confirmed that she was not intending to speak on behalf of the Ohio County Republican Party Executive Committee or any other organization.
"So you’re here in your personal capacity, not representing another organization," the mayor said.
"No organization - the citizens of Wheeling, West Virginia," Dittmar said. "Because they don’t want to come up here and be threatened like I am."
Dittmar said that she read about "Pride on the Plaza" in the newspaper. She alluded to the controversy that followed the Ohio Valley Pride Festival at Heritage Port last summer. The event reportedly generated complaints regarding crude and offensive music and behavior at the festival - including drag queens performing acts at an event that was promoted as being family friendly.
"So June 10, there’s going to be a Pride parade, and now they’re putting it on the Market Plaza," Dittmar said, noting that the upcoming event was intended to provide a "safe, nurturing place for the LGBTQ community," according to the article.
"I don’t ever remember hearing any reports about anybody ever getting beaten up or anything because they said what they were, but that’s the agenda now," Dittmar said, adding that the article included a photograph of individuals organizing the event. The group included Councilwoman Rosemary Ketchum, Dittmar noted, leading her to conclude that the city apparently supports and endorses things that are going to take place at the event.
She said another catalyst for holding the planned event was in response to what happened when a Pittsburgh company attempted to hold a drag lunch at the Primanti Brothers restaurant in The Highlands a few months ago. The brunch was canceled because organizers said they were threatened, Dittmar noted.
"The county commissioners talked to Primanti’s. I talked to Primanti’s. There were never any threats," she said, turning to comments that she had made in opposition to the Highlands drag lunch in a public restaurant. "Here were the ‘threats’ - these ‘threats’ are from me: ‘there will be plenty of media. There will be plenty of exposure. There will be lots of attention.’
Dittmar alleged that the restaurant did not want to "take that risk when you have children coming to a drag brunch," along with unknowing people and families from the general public walking into the establishment.
While Dittmar has noted that she has received threats in the wake of the Highlands situation, others have commended her for standing up for what she believes.
"Ever since this has happened, I had a woman approach me at the gym and start hugging me and praying over me for helping our kids in this city," she said, adding that police officers from another West Virginia community also offered her protection if she needed it.
"I’m going to continue on my path of fighting for this," she said, asserting that the place for drag shows should not be in the open public and around children. "When I was growing up, this was against the law and child abuse. What if someone has to walk into the (WVU Medicine) doctor’s urgent care and be confronted with things going on there?"
Councilman Ben Seidler stormed out of the meeting during Dittmar’s presentation. He slammed the door of council chambers loudly on his way out.
"There is no place for hate in this community," Seidler said afterward. "As a lifelong Christian conservative, I can tell you that nobody has ever been willingly brought to the foot of the cross by someone acting like a jerk in the name of Jesus. This person's continued hate and bigotry doesn't represent me as a Christian or me as a conservative, and quite frankly, I'm sick of hearing it.
"I don't know how she was appointed as the chair of the local Republican Party, but if this is what this party represents now, I'll hand in my Republican voter registration card tomorrow, and you can consider me fiercely independent moving forward. I'll say it again. Hate has no place here."