Breaking News
Top Headlines

Potential Testimony in William Carman Murder Trial Debated at Hearing in Ohio County

By EMMA DELK 3 min read
WILLIAM CARMAN

WHEELING -- Whether a defendant's prior domestic violence accusations from his ex-wife can be used in his upcoming murder trial is a matter that won't be decided until that information is brought up during that trial, a circuit court judge said Monday.

The attorneys for William Ross Carman -- scheduled to go to trial July 31 for the 2021 murder of Anorah Schostag -- wanted to impeach the testimony of his ex-wife Amanda Carman during Monday's hearing at the Ohio County Courthouse. Assistant Ohio County Prosecutor Shawn Turak told Circuit Judge David Sims she's not even sure where that evidence would fit into the trial.

Schostag was found dead in her South Frazier Street home on Sept. 17, 2021, with wounds to her chest and neck. Wheeling Police saw William Carman walking through the front yard of the crime scene and ordered him to stop. Carman instead fled, but was taken into custody following a brief pursuit. He has been charged with first degree murder, robbery, burglary and gross neglect of a child.

William Carman's attorney Martin Sheehan said he anticipated Amanda Carman would testify about alleged prior domestic disputes. When Sims asked Sheehan to clarify, he stated, "a variety of things, including estrangement from her husband and some issues that arose with that."

Sheehan referenced that Amanda Carman had previously told probation officers about her husband giving her a hard time, even "stalking her," which the defense believes is false.

Amanda Carman was in the process of divorcing William Carman when Schostag was killed. That divorce is now final.

Assistant Public Defender Nicholas Yovich explained that Amanda Carman had given "lengthy statements" to police regarding her relationship with William Carman at the time, which they find "relevant to the homicide."

He confirmed that the defense would "potentially" bring in the domestic abuse evidence during the trial.

Those statements were not in the record because of spousal privilege -- because the Carmans were married at the time, Amanda Carman was not compelled to testify.

Sims asked Turak whether prosecutors would question Amanda Carman about prior domestic issues. Turak said she does "not even know where that evidence comes in."

"It seems to me they want to ask it, have her say something, and then try to impeach her with it," added Turak. "They're trying to open their own door, and I don't think that's permissible."

Turak argued that to take a court order and attempt to impeach Amanda Carman on it "was not proper impeachment."

"Again, you're using an order that just says there's nothing in the file,'" said Turak. "So it's not impeachment evidence, and it's not a proper document because Amanda Carman hasn't adopted it."

On how to get over the hurdle that there was nothing found in probation officer records recording domestic abuse, Sims said, "I guess it's a jury question."

"If she told a probation officer and he didn't write it down, it's not in the records," he added, concluding the matter was a "trial issue."

"If the evidence comes in, and you're not gonna introduce it, and they open to door to it, I don't know what happens then," Sims said to Turak.

"If Carman has prior domestic violence convictions or allegations, I don't know," Sims said to the defense, "it's opening the door to things you don't want to open the door to."

Starting at /week.