Breaking News
Top Headlines

Federal Judge Rules In Favor Of Bank Over Defaulted Pandemic Loan To Justice’s Greenbrier

By STEVEN ALLEN ADAMS For the Sunday News-Register 4 min read
U.S. Sen. Jim Justice, seen here at a West Virginia Republican Party election night watch party on Nov. 3, was dinged by a federal judge earlier this week for a COVID-19 business loan taken out for the Greenbrier Resort when he was the majority owner of the historic hotel.

CHARLESTON - A federal judge ruled this week that the repayment plan for a COVID-19 pandemic-era loan to U.S. Sen. Jim Justice's Greenbrier Resort, of which he is now a minority owner, was breached.

In a memorandum opinion and order released Wednesday, Chief U.S. District Judge Frank W. Volk granted a motion for summary judgement sought by First Guaranty Bank against Greenbrier Hotel LLC, ruling that the borrower undeniably violated the repayment schedule and failed to establish any contractual obligation requiring the lender to modify the debt agreement.

"The gravamen of Greenbrier's contention supposes FGB possessed a duty to accept Greenbrier's modification request to prevent and/or cure Greenbrier's default," Volk wrote. "Greenbrier does not direct the Court to the contractual or bargained-for source of this purported obligation. Indeed, at no point does Greenbrier assert FGB owed any such duty under the Note's terms, nor does a review of the loan documents provide as much."

"There is thus no legal basis to support Greenbrier's contention that FGB breached the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing absent an obligation under the Note's terms requiring FGB to accept Greenbrier's modification request," Volk continued.

Louisiana-based First Guaranty Bank filed suit against the Greenbrier Hotel Corp. on July 17, 2024, over a $35 million loan from 2020. The Greenbrier was delinquent as of Dec. 22, 2023, and now is in default.

The loan, made through the Federal Reserve’s Main Street Lending Program under the Trump-era CARES Act during the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic, partnered for-profit companies and nonprofit organizations to provide loans with five-year maturity rates. The loans had no payments due for the first year, only required payments on interest in the second year, then 15% of the loan amount in years three and four. By year five, the entire amount of the loan plus interest was due.

FGB, whose board chairman is Huntington-based businessman Marshall Reynolds, initiated a breach-of-contract lawsuit after the Greenbrier failed to make required repayment on the loan. In response, the Greenbrier company filed counterclaims alleging the bank breached its duty of good faith and fair dealing by refusing to alter the loan terms and by incorrectly including a negative pledge restriction on its assets.

In August, the Justice family and New York-based financial firm Kennedy Lewis Investment Management announced the finalization of a joint agreement for a $500 million non-binding financing proposal to pay off major creditors and cover the costs of capital improvements at the resort. The finances would be secured by the resort and connected properties and land and timber assets owned by the Justice family and guaranteed by the senator and other family members.

The Justices and KLIM created a new holding company, with KLIM having 51% controlling interest and the Justice family holding a 49% minority interest. KLIM appointed Lloyd Nathan, with a background in hospitality and gaming with 10 years with MGM Resorts International, as chairman of the Greenbrier's board of directors. Sen. Justice’s daughter, Dr. Jill Justice, is also on the five-member board. She previously served as president of the hotel.

Volk ordered the Greenbrier to pay FGB $35 million and another $17 million, for a total of $52 million.

"The Greenbrier is aware of (the) ruling and respectfully disagrees with the decision," according to a spokesperson for the Greenbrier. "We are carefully reviewing all legal options, including appeal, to determine the appropriate next steps. The Greenbrier remains focused on serving its guests, supporting employees, and continuing its longstanding role in the community.”

Justice, a coal and agriculture magnate, bought the Greenbrier from railroad company CSX in 2009. Justice went on to become governor, first as a Democrat and later switching to Republican, in 2017. He was elected to serve in the U.S. Senate in 2024, succeeding former U.S. Sen. Joe Manchin.

Earlier this month, Justice was admonished by the Senate Ethics for missing several deadlines and extensions for filing his annual financial disclosure form. Justice cited the complications caused by the new deal with KLIM for the Greenbrier, as well as a family issue for his accountant.

"Over the summer, our family businesses were dealing with a highly complex legal dispute over the future of the Greenbrier," Justice said in a statement. "During this time, our great friend and longtime accountant was dealing with the terminal illness of his wife. Admittedly, we did not fully appreciate the significance of filing the financial disclosure late. Nevertheless, it should have been filed on time, period. It won't happen again."

Starting at /week.