Trending
Old habits are hard to break. Change is difficult. Yet in 2014 West Virginia voters decided the way we'd always done things wasn't working very well. For the first time in 80 years, we handed control of both chambers of the Legislature to Republicans.
Since then, change has been too rapid for special interests that controlled our state for generations. They have fought new ideas tooth and nail.
Now we are on the verge of a course correction in how we tax businesses. Economic development experts say that, although other shifts regarding job creators have helped, we need to check off this one major box to become truly attractive to new businesses.
It is the property tax on equipment and some inventory used by businesses. Nearly all other states have eliminated it, making West Virginia an "outlier." The tax is an objection to our state cited by job creators, we are told.
Obviously, a certain liberal wing of the Democratic Party hates the idea of eliminating the tax because the thought of withdrawing government's hand from people's pockets is anathema to them. If theirs was the only objection, it would be relatively easy for lawmakers to vote in favor of the change -- which could not be implemented without a vote of the people to amend the state constitution.
There are other reasonable concerns. Proceeds from the tax in question go to local governments, including public schools. One can understand why county-level officials would be concerned about losing around $100 million a year in revenue.
Proponents of the measure say they have a strategy to "hold harmless" the localities. They also have a sweetener for voters. Back to that in a moment.
For starters, the $100 million cut would be phased in over six years. That sounds good -- because if, in the first few years, matters go south, legislators could make up for the $16 million to $32 million loss with relative ease.
In the longer run, more money would be needed. Part of it could be raised by reductions in government spending, say proponents. But that wouldn't be enough, so the plan includes a sales tax increase, boosting the current 6% to 6.5%.
Ah-ha! There's the rub. We'd all pay another half-cent on many of our purchases.
Back to the sweetener for voters: The proposal also includes authority to kill the property tax on cars, trucks and other vehicles. If done all at once, that would cost $200 million a year.
Yes, it's complicated. Opponents have plenty of ammunition: higher sales taxes and potential loss of funding for schools and other local government functions.
Why take the chance?
It's very simple: In case you hadn't noticed, West Virginia's economy isn't the best in the nation. There's no reason to think we can lure providers of the good jobs we need unless we do something dramatic. We need to go out on a limb.
Do we have the courage to do that? Or will we continue hoping someone can wave a magic wand and make things better? Will we continue to insist on guarantees that are impossible to issue?
That's what it boils down to, folks. Nothing ventured, nothing gained.
Do we West Virginians have the guts to go for it?
Myer can be reached at: mmyer@theintelligencer.net.