Breaking News
Local Columns

Reporter’s Notebook: Deeds And Disclosures

By STEVEN ALLEN ADAMS 6 min read

I feel like the first part of last week was overshadowed by the story, first broken by West Virginia Watch, that State Auditor Mark Hunt may have violated state law by personally signing delinquent property tax deeds for a friend who provided paid advice to the State Auditor’s Office last year.

Many time, we reporters at different outlets are working on very similar things. Credit to Amelia Knisely and Henry Culvyhouse for digging through online deed records. I ended up doing a Freedom of Information Act request seeking the same data, so I confirmed much of their reporting.

I won’t rehash everything that has been reported. But to summarize, we’re talking about nine delinquent property tax deeds signed by Hunt for a real estate company owned by the wife of Charleston attorney and businessman Robert Johns.

State Code allows these types of contracts to be signed only by the deputy commissioner of delinquent and nonentered lands. The law also requires them to be signed within a 120-day period and if not signed during that period, then that triggers civil actions that must be taken by those trying to buy the property or the original landowner.

Hunt has had multiple defenses for his actions, many he laid out last week on WV MetroNews Talkline. Since the deputy commissioner is within the Land Division of the State Auditor’s Office, Hunt believes he has legal authority to sign those contracts. State Sen. Ryan Weld, the lawmaker who drafted the most recent update in 2022 to the state’s delinquent land sale laws, disagrees.

“The deputy land commissioner is appointed by the auditor, under his authority, as the land commissioner. It doesn’t say that the land commissioner, AND his authority, can sign these deeds because (Hunt) is in charge of everybody. They specifically state that these deeds are issued by the deputy land commissioner.”

In short, that’s like saying State Superintendent of Schools Michele Blatt can one day show up at a school and start teaching a math class. She has the supervisory authority of the state’s public school system, yes, but that does not empower her to walk into a classroom and start grading students.

Hunt also threw previous state auditor and current Attorney General J.B. McCuskey under the bus, claiming that the Land Division Hunt inherited from McCuskey was behind and in “disarray.” McCuskey has denied this, but let’s say that’s true. How is it the only deeds I can find from the beginning of Hunt’s term that he signed personally are these nine deeds for the company Johns’ wife owns? If there was a backlog of these types of deeds that needed personally signed by Hunt, should others have popped up in my FOIA request?

As I reported, one of those deeds was one Johns’ company buying the delinquent tax deed for another company owned by Johns. Explain that one to me. Johns himself was paid $14,000 for consultancy work for the State Auditor’s Office last year. His wife was a donor to Hunt’s state senate and auditor campaigns. Make it make sense.

Much like when it was reported that Hunt’s office hired a sitting Republican state senator as an employee against the advice of the Attorney General’s Office and in blatant violation of the state Constitution, Hunt’s attitude has been arrogance and defiance. I’m not sure that’s going to keep working, especially if a federal grand jury is also sniffing around his office for reasons that are not yet clear.

—

In October’s Reporter’s Notebook, I wrote the following:

“I won’t predict what the Supreme Court will do in regard to (3rd Circuit Court Judge Tim) Sweeney’s admonishment, but I detected some skepticism of Sweeney’s charges by some of the (state Supreme Court) justices.”

Well, the Supreme Court upheld Sweeney’s admonishment in an order last Thursday for his order nearly two years ago that state child welfare officials report to Ritchie County to help with the understaffing in the regional CPS office. His admonishment for re-posting local law enforcement Facebook posts was also upheld.

This is why I don’t make predictions in print. Though privately, I assumed the court would probably dismiss the admonishment while chiding Sweeney for his order, while well intentioned. Except for having to pay the court costs, it’s still largely a performative admonishment, meant more to send a message to other judges and magistrates.

Now, will this actually encourage the justices, who oversee the entire state judicial system, to perhaps look in the mirror and see how they have contributed to the state’s child welfare and foster care crisis? That remains to be seen. Again, I won’t make a prediction.

—

The political operatives are already hard at work ahead of the 2028 GOP primary for governor. It remains to be seen when, or if, U.S. Sen. Jim Justice decides to run for a third term and challenge Gov. Patrick Morrisey. But Morrisey operatives were quick to text reporters the letter issued by the Senate Ethics Committee Tuesday admonishing Justice for missing several deadlines and extensions for filing his annual financial disclosure form.

I have reported in the past on Justice delaying his financial disclosure reports. He did this in 2024 during his U.S. Senate campaign and again last year. Justice did file his report this year in early September, but he blew through various deadlines and extensions.

The letter seems more like a boilerplate slap-on-the-hand thing. But the Morrisey people seem to think this will be the thing that finally makes people care about the long list of things Justice is supposed to do or pay. We will see, but having covered Justice for his first year in the Senate and seven out of eight years as governor, I am skeptical this is the thing that will get Toby and Edith incensed.

—

Finally, John Findlay, a GOP political consultant and former state Republican Party executive director, showed the state Thursday on WV MetroNews Talkline the side of him that lawmakers saw behind the scenes when he was Gov. Morrisey’s director of intergovernmental and political affairs last year, and the side of him many reporters saw this year as a consultant for the political action committee affiliated with Senate President Randy Smith, R-Preston.

Some passion is fine, especially when debating someone who disagrees with you. But losing control on statewide talk radio, banging on the table, and dropping an expletive one can definitely not say on the FCC-regulated airwaves? T.J. Meadows and Dave Wilson did not ask for or deserve that.

Starting at /week.