Breaking News
Local Columns

John McCabe: School Enrollment Data Shows Need for Urgency

6 min read

How West Virginia funds its public schools is shaping up to be one of the defining issues in the upcoming legislative session.

Lawmakers already have heard from the West Virginia Department of Education that an additional $410 million is needed immediately for the state's 55 county school systems. There's talk of a total revamping of the 1982 decision by the late Ohio County Circuit Judge Arthur Recht, which provided, at that time, for a "thorough and efficient" system of funding public schools.

Public school funding already is a major line item in the state budget. Locally, our six county school districts from Tyler to Hancock are set to spend $431 million on educating students in fiscal year 2027, according to their budgets.

That level of spending on public education just in our region surprised me. The bigger shock came when I went through enrollment data for those six counties.

Going back to the 2009-10 school year, the six Northern Panhandle counties -- Ohio, Marshall, Brooke, Hancock, Wetzel and Tyler -- enrolled 22,314 students, according to West Virginia Department of Education data. Fast forward to this current school year, and those counties today enroll 16,557 students -- a 26% decline.

It might seem odd to pick 2009-10 for an enrollment data comparison, but that also was the earliest year for which the state provided school district budgets.

As noted above, this current fiscal year sees the counties in our region spending $431 million to operate their districts. In 2009, that figure was $189.2 million.

So, at the same time we've seen a 26% decrease in public school student enrollment just in our Northern Panhandle counties, we've also seen a 128% increase in spending locally on public education.

Adjusting for inflation, that $189.2 million in 2009 is equivalent to about $300 million today.

My thoughts as I write this, though, are not simply why, as an additional $130 million locally is available for public education (not factoring for inflation) and we're educating fewer students, more money is needed. That's a question I'm certain lawmakers will be posing to education leaders during the session. Instead, I want to focus on another number -- 5,757 -- which represents how many fewer public schools' students there are today in our local counties than there were in 2009-10.

As I was considering these numbers, I kept coming back to that 5,757 figure because I believe it tells us something about the Northern Panhandle that goes well beyond what it costs to run our schools.

That figure makes me think about the children who were in elementary school in our region in 2009 -- including two of my own. Many are now old enough to have entered the workforce and possibly even have children of their own. How many are raising those children here? How many had to leave to find the kind of work they wanted to do? And how many would come back today if they thought they could build a life here?

Again, the numbers: in fiscal 2009, the public schools locally enrolled 22,314 students. The fiscal 2027 figure is 16,557. That's a decline of 26%. Go back to the 2000-01 school year and the enrollment decline rises to 33%.

In little more than a generation, we've lost a third of our public school enrollment. If that doesn't make you stop and think about the future we need to build, I'm not sure what will.

Every one of our six counties has fewer students than it did in 2009. In Brooke County, enrollment fell from 3,423 to 2,046, a drop of 40%. In Ohio County, the decline was about 16%.

The bigger question, though, is this: what are we doing to stem this flow? This isn't about students going to a private school because of the Hope Scholarship. This isn't about parents making the decision to homeschool. What this is about is an area that needs a vision of the future, one in which we encourage new businesses to locate here through the creation of a business and regulatory climate that takes advantage of our location between Pittsburgh and Columbus.

We need to decide today what kind of community we want our region to be in 20 years. Personally, I want it to be a place where our children can find work in the fields they've chosen, buy a home they can afford and raise a family close to the people who raised them. I want it to be a place where someone with no ties to the Ohio Valley can come here for a job, experience the exceptional quality of life we offer (great public parks, low crime, exceptional amenities) and decide to stay.

Getting there will take hard decisions -- and those decisions need to start today. Where do we want new businesses to locate, and what are we willing to do to get those sites ready? Where can we build new housing or fix up the homes we already have? Those are questions I know our county commissions, city councils and development officials already are working through together. If we don't do that, then we will experience more of the same. That will lead to even tougher decisions -- which schools to consolidate, for example. Nobody wants that.

***

I noticed on my drive in to work Friday morning that the folks at Wheeling's wastewater treatment plant have placed a giant green inflatable dinosaur out front for Christmas. Give them credit. After several months of that primordial stench drifting through Center Wheeling, they've finally found a decoration from the right geological period.

***

It's easy to walk through Wheeling and never give a second thought to a curb cut or a storefront entrance. That changes when you're the one trying to get through in a wheelchair or pushing a stroller.

On Saturday, Nov. 28, the Accessibility Stroll will give folks a chance to see where getting around downtown and Center Wheeling could be easier.

The free, all-ages walk-and-roll will start at 11 a.m. at Centre Market, head up Main Street to the Suspension Bridge and return along Market Street. Along the way, participants will take note of trouble spots on sidewalks, at crossings and at building entrances. I'd be especially interested in what we hear from the folks who have to navigate those spots every day.

One of the organizers of this event is Eleanor Hortert, an exceptional young lady with a heart of gold. My family has had the pleasure of getting to know her and her family through soccer, as her sister and my youngest daughter have played together for a number of years.

Organizers are also asking local businesses to pitch in with gift cards, discounts, small giveaways or refreshments. If you'd like to help or want to know more about taking part, call Accessibility Committee Chair Faith Hicks at 304-280-7819 or email her at faithhicks930@gmail.com.

John McCabe is editor of The Intelligencer and Wheeling News-Register. He can be reached at jmccabe@theintelligencer.net.

Starting at /week.