W.Va. Attorney General Seeks Dismissal Of School Aid Formula Lawsuit On Behalf Of Lawmakers
Trending
CHARLESTON – The West Virginia Attorney General’s Office, acting on behalf of legislative leadership, wants the state’s highest court to throw out the lawsuit brought on behalf of a Lincoln County parent to force changes to the school aid formula.
According to a motion filed last week during an automatic stay of a case originally brought by the ACLU-WV, the Attorney General’s Office filed a motion with the West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals to dismiss on the grounds of legislative immunity and a lack of petitioner standing on behalf of the legislative clients and executive branch officials.
“Petitioner takes issue with the Legislature's choice not to pass a school funding bill to her preferred specifications,” wrote Principal Deputy Solicitor General Holly Wilson. “She wants this Court to order the Speaker of the House of Delegates and the President of the Senate to compel the Legislature to pass a bill more to her liking – and now. But when the Legislature's choices disappoint, the Constitution's answer is an election, not a writ. Unsurprisingly, then, the Court lacks jurisdiction twice over.”
The ACLU-WV filed a petition at the end of September over the school aid formula on behalf of Lincoln County resident Lakin Patten and her child, seeking an order from the state Supreme Court determining that the Legislature, members of the Board of Public Works, members of the Lincoln County Board of Education and state education and tax officials have violated their constitutional duty to maintain a "thorough and efficient" public school system.
Put in place following a 1982 legal case, the school aid formula distributes funding to the state's 55-county school systems based heavily on public school enrollment numbers finalized every October. While not the only source of funding for county school districts, the school aid funding formula plays a large role in county school budgets. But decades of reductions in student enrollment have caused counties to make hard budgeting decisions, including layoffs and school closing/consolidations.
In her filing, Wilson argued that attorneys with the ACLU-WV have not shown how actions by the Legislature are the cause of the educational challenges the parents and their children are facing in Lincoln County or whether those families’ pay taxes. Wilson also argues that West Virginia's constitutional Speech or Debate Clause allows for legislative immunity, shielding the Legislature from the lawsuit.
“The Petition tries to hold the Legislative Respondents to account for passing legislation and then deciding when or how to amend it,” Wilson wrote. “West Virginia's Constitution, alongside two statutes, immunizes the Legislative Respondents from suit based on those acts. They thus deprive this Court of jurisdiction over claims against those Respondents.”
The Attorney General’s Office also continues to ask the Supreme Court to grant a motion for abeyance on behalf of the Legislature and state officials to delay the lawsuit until after Saturday, March 13, when the 2027 regular session of the Legislature ends. Attorneys for the state Board of Education and State Superintendent of Schools Michele Blatt, who recently filed a finding acknowledging the issues raised by the ACLU-WV, also support abeyance.
The state Department of Education (WVDE) proposed draft legislation last month to overhaul the school aid funding formula, presenting an overview of that plan to lawmakers last week during interim meetings.
Among other things, the WVDE proposal would create a new funding enrollment mechanism that calculates base funding using the higher of the prior year’s second-month net enrollment or a three-year average, shielding districts from abrupt revenue cliffs caused by declining enrollment. It would replace a flat per-pupil allocation with specific funding weights for special education students tiered by service intensity, low socioeconomic status/poverty, English learners, career and technical education, gifted students and rurality.
In a response filed on Nov. 9, attorneys with the ACLU-WV said they opposed the motion for abeyance, arguing that a court ruling would send a stronger message than continuing to wait on the Legislature to make needed reforms on its own.
“For years, West Virginia's students and schools have been given false hope and empty promises concerning reform to the school aid formula, always being told that an adequately funded education is right around the next corner,” wrote ACLU-WV Legal Director Aubrey Sparks. “Despite this, the promised relief has historically failed to materialize.”
“The long wait for adequate educational funding has taken a toll; buildings have decayed, classrooms have been deprived of certified and qualified teachers, and students have been denied adequate remedial education,” Sparks continued. “The present action is before this Court because the wait was too long, the cost of inaction too high, to permit another legislative session to proceed without clear guidance from this Court as to what is constitutionally required of the Respondents.”