Breaking News
Community

Man Who Robbed the Up on the Lane Cafe on Edgington Lane in Wheeling Sentenced to 6-23 Years in Prison

By Robert A. DeFrank 3 min read
Photo by Robert A. DeFrank Eduardo Alvendia is sentenced Wednesday to serve six to 23 years in prison for robbing the Up on the Lane cafe on Edgington Lane last April.

The man convicted by a jury of second-degree robbery and conspiracy to commit robbery of the Up on the Lane cafe on Edgington Lane last April 15 was sentenced Wednesday by Ohio County Circuit Court Judge David Sims.

Eduardo Alvendia, his defense attorney and his mother asked that his drug addiction issues be considered as a factor in his sentencing, but Sims noted that Alvendia used an air pistol that looked like a real firearm to obtain almost $6,000 and imposed a sentence of six to 23 years in prison. According to court records, Alvendia, 35, of Wheeling was convicted March 19. His girlfriend and co-defendant allegedly held the door of the business open wide enough that it could not lock, then Alvendia entered and threatened the clerk.

Alvendia said he regrets committing the robbery.

"My addiction has led me to do some terrible things, this being the worst," he told the judge. "I wish I could change the past, but I can't. I would like to say that I regret every decision I have made involved in this whole situation. I never meant to harm anyone, especially the clerk. I'm truly sorry for everyone affected by this ordeal."

His defense attorney, Ann Marie Morelli, asked Sims to consider that Alvendia has no prior violent felonies on his criminal record. She requested a flat sentence of five years for the robbery and a concurrent sentence for the conspiracy charge.

"The decisions he was making that led to this crime were made through his addiction. He understands he made a mistake, a huge one," Morelli said. "Eddy Alvendia is not a monster, he is an addict who needs help."

Assistant Prosecutor Brian Ghaphery recommended longer, consecutive sentences, saying Alvendia's actions rose to the level of contributing to violent crime in the community. He added that Alvendia threatened the clerk's life.

"She had no idea if this was a real gun or not. As far as she knew, she was going to get shot that day," Ghaphery said. "It was planned, it was violent, and she was in fear for her life."

Ghaphery added that while Alvendia has no prior violent felony convictions, he was on probation in Belmont County for a theft charge when this crime was committed.

"This is unfortunately the beginning of a pattern of criminal activity that has now escalated into a violent crime, and there's no reason to think that without proper punishment this won't happen again," he said, adding that Alvendia had taken no responsibility for the crime prior to sentencing. He added that there are recordings of his calls from jail shortly before the trial, telling his co-defendant that she would need to lie for him.

Sims said a longer sentence was merited and sentenced Alvendia to five to 18 years for the robbery charge and one to five years for the conspiracy charge, to be served consecutively for a net effective sentence of six to 23 years.

"I see people with addiction issues … almost every day," Sims said. "You've done a lot of damage to that clerk. She'll probably never forget this incident. You were late to the game to accept responsibility also. … You're another casualty in the war on drugs, and it's sad, and until somebody changes something in this country and does something about drug policy, we'll do this every day."

Starting at /week.