Breaking News
Top Headlines

Wheeling City Council Hears Mixed Opinions on User Fee

By ALEX MEYER 4 min read
Councilwoman Wendy Scatterday, far left, speaks to members of Wheeling City Council at the body’s meeting Tuesday.

WHEELING -- As Wheeling City Council floated enacting a user fee at its meeting Tuesday, it heard from residents both for and against the measure intended to fund a proposed $14.5 million public safety building.

Council heard the first reading of an ordinance to adopt the weekly $2 fee and could vote on the matter at its next meeting Aug. 20. Members fielded questions, complaints and endorsements from several residents regarding the fee and public safety building.

The user fee, also dubbed a city service fee, would apply to all full-time, part-time and self-employed workers who work in Wheeling for at least 30 days per year. The ordinance under consideration was modeled after a similar one enacted in Charleston, Mayor Glenn Elliott said.

City Manager Robert Herron explained the legality of the user fee after Councilman Dave Palmer said he had been questioned as to whether the ordinance would violate home rule.

The use fee would not violate home rule, Herron said, and predates the creation of the Municipal Home Rule Pilot Program in 2007. Specifically, section 8-13-13 of West Virginia code allows for "special charges for municipal services."

"This ordinance is not an amendment to our home rule plan. It does have to be designated for a specific purpose, which this ordinance does do. The ordinance that you're considering here over the next couple weeks is very, very similar to the Charleston user fee which has been tested in West Virginia Supreme Court on at least two occasions."

Wheeling's ordinance has also been fully reviewed by the city's bond counsel twice in the past year, Herron said.

During the public comment portion of the meeting, council heard an endorsement from Wheeling Professional Firefighters Local 12 regarding the fee. President Tom Haluscak said the public safety building is much needed and that the union supports the council.

"We cannot continue to put Band-Aids on our crumbling infrastructure and put zip ties on our apparatus," Haluscak said. "On that end, we are very grateful to council and Mayor Elliott for finding a path forward that would allow the city of Wheeling to modernize the resources available for its first responders."

One dollar of the fee would go toward public safety and the other $1 would go toward infrastructure, officials said previously. The $2 fee is estimated to generate $1.75 million per year, Vice Mayor Chad Thalman said Monday.

"Half of that would go toward much needed infrastructure, our streets and sidewalks," Haluscak said. "Past councils have kicked the can down the road because they knew those shortcomings weren't going to be on their hands. I realize this is a difficult decision, but we didn't elect you for the easy stuff."

Debra Moore, a resident of Martins Ferry, asked council how Wheeling could tax workers who live in Ohio.

"To expect employees that reside in a completely different state to cover services that are actually forced upon, this is what this fee does, because it's withdrawn from people's paychecks," Moore said.

Elliott responded that the fee is made legal through state code and Supreme Court decisions, has been enacted in six other large West Virginia cities and would serve as a flat fee, not an income tax.

Wheeling resident Charles Beluze similarly expressed dissatisfaction with the user fee and requested that council remove the fee after the building is paid for. Elliott noted that the ordinance includes a sunset clause, which would put the matter up for renewal by city council in 25 years.

Ohio County resident Wendy Elswick said she thinks council should pass the user fee. She then presented a check for her annual share of the fee dated Jan. 1, 2020 -- when the fee would go into effect -- to City Council.

"Let's get this done, get it for the guys that need it, let them have the space that they need," Elswick said. "Move on so we're not in a circular wheel or something here."

Two other residents expressed concern with the 19th Street site where Wheeling aims to construct the building and the tentative $534,000 purchase price for the property. The most recent appraised value of the property was $43,300, according to the Ohio County Assessor's Office.

"We're going to continue to work to get that price down," Elliott said. "We couldn't be in more agreement with you that that price is too high. What is on the assessor's site is not always accurate. But the building we could build there is about $6 million cheaper than the one we were going to build downtown."

Residents also suggested the city use eminent domain to acquire the property rather than purchasing it. Elliott previously said he doesn't believe the standard to use eminent domain is met by the property and that using it would set a dangerous precedent.

Starting at /week.